CHICAGO - Federal appeals court judges considering whether to uphold gay marriage bans in Indiana and Wisconsin are reserving their toughest questions for the states, asking how the bans help society, especially children of same-sex couples.
A three-judge panel of the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals heard oral arguments in the case Tuesday.
Judge Richard Posner, the panel's lone Republican appointee, bristled when a Wisconsin assistant attorney general repeatedly pointed to "tradition."
Posner said "it was tradition to not allow blacks and whites to marry." He also asked how children of same-sex couples benefit.
Judge David Hamilton pressed lawyers opposing the bans, asking whether they would argue for polygamy on similar grounds.
American Civil Liberties Union attorney Kenneth Falk said two people defined a marriage, and "there's no slippery slope."
- Family remembers fire that took 4 kids' lives 25 years later
- Plea deal reached in killing of 13-year-old girl in 1982
- Madison Club donation focuses on 100 Black Men, achievement gap
- Madison Metro bus driver retires after half a century
- City streets dept. denies telling MMSD roads were OK
- Icy conditions send more people to ER for falls