Channel3000.comMadison News


E-Mail News Alerts
Get breaking news and daily headlines.
Browse all e-mail newsletters
Related To Story

Study: Respiratory Symptoms Decrease At City's Smoking Ban

Ban Opponents Disagree With Report

UPDATED: 7:55 pm CST February 27, 2006

University of Wisconsin-Madison researchers released the results on Monday of a study that appears to reconfirm the public health effects touted by supporters of smoking bans.

Watch The Report

Opponents, however, are questioning the study and seeking to discredit it.

Researchers at the UW Comprehensive Cancer Center surveyed 400 bartenders before and after the smoking bans in bars and restaurants passed in Madison eight months ago.

The data was released at the Harmony Bar on Atwood Avenue in Madison on Monday afternoon.

The study found that respiratory symptoms, including wheezing, shortness of breath and coughing, were cut by 40 percent after the smoking ban took effect.

Dr. Patrick Remington, a researcher at the Comprehensive Cancer Center, said that the study's results demonstrate the positive effects of the ban.

"This shows convincingly that the health of the bartenders has improved within only after a few months of the policies being put into place," he said. "It reduces their current symptoms, and it'll reduce their risk of disease in the long run."

The study's data was collected from the written surveys. The only actual medical test performed was on lung function, and only 73 of the bartenders had that test, WISC-TV reported.

Remington said those tests yielded interesting results.

"We did pulmonary tests," Remington said. "That's a test of just how well the lungs are working, and we found that non-smokers between before the ordinance went into effect and afterwards had a significant improvement in their pulmonary function."

The smoking ban has been in effect since last July and has sparked controversy over whether it has hurt area businesses.

Remington said that the study results show the discussion should now be about the positive public health impacts and not the impact the ban has had on businesses.

Several bar owners have said that business is down significantly.

A spokesman for the Coalition To Save Madison Jobs, an anti-smoking ban group, questioned the science of the study and called it a joke, WISC-TV reported.




Links We Like
Talking about sex and dating with your kids can be uncomfortable but it is absolutely necessary. Get tips on how to approach these difficult subjects. More Details

Now is the time for you to buy your first home. Find out everything you need to know to make the process smooth and easy. More Details

Face it, your resume is out of date. Catch up to the times and refresh that retro resume. More Details

Itchy, dry skin can have many origins as well as solutions. Find out how to make it stop and make your skin healthier. More Details

Like online video? Then you'll love Now See This.

Links We Like includes a selection of information, tools and resources from our partners and sponsors.

Premium Weather

Premium Weather
How will the weather affect you? Know for sure. Monitor storms, animate your forecast, create personal alerts! Try it now! or Log in here.