Health Care Quality Gap Blamed For Thousands Of Deaths
Annual Report Suggests Polarized Health System
Posted: 10:11 am EDT September 23, 2004
WASHINGTON -- Routine failure to provide needed health care in the United States came with the price tag of $1.8 billion in additional medical costs and up to 79,000 avoidable deaths, according to a new study. In its annual report, the private National Committee for Quality Assurance said there was some improvement last year in the care offered by the nation's managed care organizations.
The performance improvements recorded last year among the 563 health plans that reported their results -- covering about 69 million people -- were among the largest ever."The data we have tell a great story: Health care quality for some is improving consistently and dramatically," said NCQA President Margaret O'Kane. "But we only have data for accountable health plans. Why don't we have performance data for the other 75 percent of the U.S. health care system? All types of health plans, hospitals and doctors should report on their performance. How else can we make informed choices?" But the report found wide variations in the treatment of conditions including high blood pressure and diabetes, as well as in breast cancer screening and flu shots for adults. And no gains were made in the area of treating mental illness.The findings suggest that the system is deeply polarized, delivering excellent care to some people and generally poor care to many others."Purchasers see these quality gaps at the same time they are facing the fourth straight year of double-digit price increases," said Peter Lee, president and CEO of Pacific Business Group on Health. "This report underscores that all too often, we are not getting good value for that money."The report includes suggestions on improving quality, including a pay-for-performance plans for doctors so they would have the incentive to apply best practice care. Currently, doctors are generally compensated based on the amount of care they provide -- not the quality of care.
|
Discuss: How Can Health Care System Be Improved?
Full Report: National Committee for Quality Assurance (Adobe Reader required) The performance improvements recorded last year among the 563 health plans that reported their results -- covering about 69 million people -- were among the largest ever."The data we have tell a great story: Health care quality for some is improving consistently and dramatically," said NCQA President Margaret O'Kane. "But we only have data for accountable health plans. Why don't we have performance data for the other 75 percent of the U.S. health care system? All types of health plans, hospitals and doctors should report on their performance. How else can we make informed choices?" But the report found wide variations in the treatment of conditions including high blood pressure and diabetes, as well as in breast cancer screening and flu shots for adults. And no gains were made in the area of treating mental illness.The findings suggest that the system is deeply polarized, delivering excellent care to some people and generally poor care to many others."Purchasers see these quality gaps at the same time they are facing the fourth straight year of double-digit price increases," said Peter Lee, president and CEO of Pacific Business Group on Health. "This report underscores that all too often, we are not getting good value for that money."The report includes suggestions on improving quality, including a pay-for-performance plans for doctors so they would have the incentive to apply best practice care. Currently, doctors are generally compensated based on the amount of care they provide -- not the quality of care.
| Estimated Deaths Attributable to Failure to Deliver Recommended Care | |||
| Selected Measures/Conditions (U.S. Population) | |||
| Measure | Avoidable Deaths (range) | ||
| Controlling High Blood Pressure | 15,000 - 26,000 | ||
| Cholesterol Control | 6,900 - 17,000 | ||
| Diabetes Care–HbA1c Control | 4,300 - 9,600 | ||
| Smoking Cessation (with medication) | 5,400 - 8,100 | ||
| Flu Shots | 3,500 - 7,300 | ||
| Colorectal Cancer Screening | 4,200 - 6,300 | ||
| Beta-Blocker Treatment | 900 - 1,900 | ||
| Prenatal Care | 600 - 1,400 | ||
| Breast Cancer Screening | 600 - 1,000 | ||
| Cervical Cancer Screening | 600 - 800 | ||
| Total: | 42,000 - 79,400 | ||
| Source: National Committee for Quality Assurance, 2004 Annual Report | |||
Distributed by Internet Broadcasting Systems, Inc. The Associated Press contributed to this report. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
